searchmetrics email facebook github gplus instagram linkedin phone rss twitter whatsapp youtube arrow-right chevron-up chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right clock close menu search

Graph Visibility: Adapt or Die!

Graph Visibility: Adapt or Die
Graph Visibility: Adapt or Die!

For the last few weeks Dave and I have been talking about a way of changing the way SEO’s look at link building. If you haven’t noticed most of the posts on SEO in 2013 discuss how the role of links (Linkgraph) and social (the Socialgraph) in Search Engine Algorithms is changing what SEO’s need to do to raise ranks. When I say Search Engines well that is about 80% Google so, if you are using the marketers 80/20 rule then you think Google is for the most part Search Engines.

Graph Visibility

So what is graph visibility? It’s a measurement of visibility across the Socialgraph, Linkgraph and Knowledgegraph. A while back Dave and I did a Podcast with Bill Slawski called Beyond the Linkgraph which was done right after the Knowledgegraph SERP had been announced/released by Google. One of the themes throughout the show was how the Linkgraph was being de-emphasized and cleaned up by Google.

Remember this was at a time when Panda had dampened link equity coming from article marketing, UGC and other SEO faves for foundational link building and Penguin was dampening “keyword rich links”. This was before the EMD update which dampened anchors to exact match domains. That was when I started using content strategies that consider maximum Graph visibility as the goal.

Manipulating The Graphs for Maximum Visibility

The Linkgraph is well documented and currently it’s value and role are being de-emphasized by filters and subsequent dampening of the Linkgraph signals. The Socialgraph’s buzz is a huge part in triggering the temporal/behavioral sensitivity in Google SERPs and Knowledgraph is a SERP unto itself!

The Knowledgegraph


Knowledgegraph can be the easiest or hardest to gain visibility because there are so few opportunities. The opportunities lie in the SERP itself! A Knowledgegraph result is based on things relevant to an entity. So for the Toronto Maple Leafs (go buds!) that would include information pertinent to the team history, players and “activities” associated with games like game tickets and amenity information, hrs etc. The type of content and information included in the SERP are where the opportunities can be found.

Knowledgegraph SERPs are rich in media so naturally align with content strategies for Universal Search with the image, video, news and local elements playing a role in the makeup of the SERP. I can’t remember seeing a map but there is lots of local flavor to Knowledgegraph results. SEO’s who take a SERP Out perspective on ranking now have an advantage because they have been building content that is trying to trigger elements in Universal Search for years. These SEO’s are very tuned to the temporal nature of SERPs and therefore have been using Social Buzz to trigger inclusion for their rich media content in Universal SERPs.

The Post Penguin Linkgraph

Currently the Linkgraph de-emphasis and cleanup has many SEO’s scrambling to disavow and remove links from link profiles with 10’s of thousands of links likely for the most part ignored by Google. In cleaning these up one of the surprising things was the lack of movement in rankings (unless it is Penguin/anchor related) when you start stripping away the unwanted links.

There are some cases we have seen when a penalty is in place that removing/disavowing links does help but that is almost always a manual penalty like Unnatural Linking messages. Penguin is not a penalty, it is a dampener/filter! Your techniques to combat/avoid dampening are not about changing to different techniques, but rather, the change in ratio of foundational to natural links from authority sites. Quantity of links is not a big deal the Who What and Where is where it’s at Jack!

Outreach is evolving because the new Google algos are just ignoring blogs that are obviously “for sale”. When we look at these sites with manual penalties and many have obvious footprints that appear to be blog networks. If SEO tools can uncover multiple networkst or a knowledgeable SEO can with a few searches on Google, a report from Majestic and review of a few of the blogs homepages!

Basically you can see the footprint in the front page of the “guesting blogs”. It seemed as if they followed each other around or were entities or multiple entities tracking by topic or author. Though with offshore SEO’s it is more likely to be unsophisticated implementation. One list of blogs I was given contained over 100 password and username combos to log in and edit and remove links. Yes folks…not one worked!

In the end I’m sure Google’s tools are better than anything SEO’s have cuz, well, Google have the whole Link index that counts don’t they? More importantly they have the index of links that don’t count, “the Master” disavow list and ignored links!;-)

The Socialgraph: The Noise in Your Site’s Signal to Noise Ratio!

Over the years I’ve referred to the quality of information by an entity/site in terms of signal to noise. The signal, in the signal to noise ratio, is the information. The quality/strength of the signal is the user’s “perceived value” partially represented by links (linkgraph), Shares and Likes on Google+ and possibly reading shares and likes on sites.

SEO Future Proofing: There was a time when it seemed like links in twitter feeds placed on sites were indexed, however, with so few Twitter results showing in the results it seems that, though indexable, the mighty Google ignores them, so, there is reason to doubt Google will care in the future, if they do care now, about shares and likes indexed on sites they will care much less in the future. Why would Google care when it has Google+ with profiles attached that no other engine has access to!

The Socialgraph is a huge component in triggering the temporal nature of Google SERPs. Social Signals from blogs and news; “buzz” engagement on YouTube and it’s Google+ Network are triggers to entering and owning a Universal SERP for short periods of time and maintaining enhanced SERP visibility thereafter! Google is rewarding the use of rich media. Leverage your rich media content with foundational link building techniques, outreach and down your Social channels. Multiple embeds of images and video by other sites, content aggregators and Social networks are signals though not like links did in their heydays.

The correlation of Social Signals to ranking on Google are undeniable but not causative. Looking at how the signal could be amplified it is evident quantity is less of a signal, rather, it is more about the entity sending the signal and where the signal is sent that counts. The entity will be a bigger key to success than in the past so identifying and establishing semantic relationships with entities and using author snippets in results. The fact Google is/was using user behavior to return more results for a specific author based on a click and likelihood it was read illustrates Google’s interests in basing some part of results on user behavior.

Graph Visibility Conclusion

sweet spot

Every day it becomes more evident that visibility on as many of the above graphs as possible is important. The Scoialgraph is a key to the temporal elements in SERPs. These signals verify freshness and helps measure the quality of your content. The linkgraph is evolving toward a true citation signal indicating relationship between entities and topics rather than a reflection of promotion. The Knowledgegraph is like a direct result of the link and socialgraph changes.

Now when you think about supporting your content don’t think in terms of link visibility but more along the lines of what is my graph visibility and where are the opportunities to raise visibility on the graphs most affecting the SERP you are trying to affect!

Terry Van Horne

Terry Van Horne

Terry Van Horne has been developing and marketing websites since the early 90's in various marketing and development positions including working as internet marketing manager for one of Canada's largest real estate developers; SEO for an award winning real estate search engine and marketing manager for ecommerce stores in the apparel and musical instruments. In 2007 he developed a YouTube Marketing Strategy and to date those 300+ videos have received over I8,000,000+ downloads . He is currently a partner with David Harry in Reliable SEO, a Search and Social Media Marketing Agency, and the award winning SEO Training Dojo, a learning community as well as three other marketing and industry news sites. Terry is Director Of SEO Dojo Radio and co-hosts 2 hour long podcasts "Search Geeks Speak," an hour with luminaries and up and comers in Search Engine Marketing as well as "The Regulators," an hour of Industry News. Terry founded, the first consumer advocacy organization for purchasers of search engine optimization and is currently a Director of the NFP organization OSEOP that grew out of it.

14 thoughts on “Graph Visibility: Adapt or Die!

  • Complete SEO Link Building Services 2013/01/24 at 11:04 am

    This post is really incredible, one of the most helpful I have ever read, indeed.

  • This is an incredibly informative post. I’ve never looked at it this way, but it was a good little refresher about each of the metrics.

  • Thanks man, very usefull. I am going to get a post of this on a big Dutch marketing blog also about the Graph Visibility etc. Thanks.

  • Its a great post. Thank for all.

  • It’s great to come across a post that tackles this subject really thoroughly. It’s really useful and definitely one I’ll be visiting again as we get stuck in to 2013.

    Thanks for putting the time in to produce it!

  • andrewkelly2222 2013/03/12 at 1:59 am

    SEO is really a constant rule of adaption, if you dont adapt you will get hit by the next big update

  • Great article about graph visibility! Thanks for that!

  • The best and in the same time the worst update for webmasters is not penguin, but Google search by image.
    Now duplicate content for the same image can also ban your site….

  • suspected the same of links sent to twitter, now this confirms what I thought.
    Thanks for sharing this great experience

  • Thanks for this great article. Very informative information on the link graph!

  • Useful article, It’s interesting to see how search is changing.. long gone are the days where you can just build up loads of links with your given anchor text and dominate the search engine. Hopefully this will put the quality back into SEO, Websites need to be designed with search engines in mind and social media needs to be a key part of any online marketing strategy.

    Is there any reasearch you know of that shows a correlation between social media presense, activity and search engine rankings ?

    Have noticed Google + playing more of a role recently

  • This is one of the great article which I’ve ever read, it’s so useful and accurate information. More than that everything is so good explained that even a beginner like me understand. l I’m very impressed.

  • Very useful post! This strategy will be the winning one this years so we should all do our homework and chekc our site to see if the respect the rules.

  • Quality articles or reviews is the secret to be a focus for the visitors to go
    to see the web site, that’s what this site is providing.

Write a Comment

Note: If you enter something other than a name here (such as a keyword), or if your entry seems to have been made for commercial or advertising purposes, we reserve the right to delete or edit your comment. So please only post genuine comments here!

Also, please note that, with the submission of your comment, you allow your data to be stored by To enable comments to be reviewed and to prevent abuse, this website stores the name, email address, comment text, and the IP address and timestamp of your comment. The comments can be deleted at any time. Detailed information can be found in our privacy statement.