Have you been trolled by Panda?

November 9th, 2012 | Analysis, General 5 comments

Source: http://www.sxc.hu/photo/172466

This morning my friend contacted me via Skype to ask if I knew of any problems with SearchMetrics. SearchMetrics and problems? This is something that has never happened before. So I asked him more about the problems. He answered that there has probably been a calculation error in recent weekly visibility updates. There was a weekly update yesterday (7th Nov) and I had this weird feeling that something was going to happen. My feeling was right. However I didn’t expect to see an earthquake.

Here is what I did:

First of all I checked some of the UK big-fishes. I will keep quiet who I exactly checked (their online teams have had enough of a headache today) but the results were really weird. What I saw made me think that the drop is significant and that most possibly my friend is right: there is a visibility calculation error. And maybe (just maybe) not every keyword position and exact search volume was included in the weekly update. Or maybe it could just be that an update is in-progress. Or maybe something different…? An algorithm update perhaps?

Next I decided to call Paul from SearchMetrics.
He told me that they (as in SearchMetrics) had already had a conversation about the “problem” and had come to the conclusion that it isn’t an error.
So then I checked SeoMOZ to see if there had been any recent Google algorithm updates.

I found this:

“Google rolled out their 21st Panda update, roughly 5-1/2 weeks after Panda #20. This update was reported to be smaller, officially impacting 1.1% of English queries.”

Google Releases Panda Update 21, Impacts 1.1% Of US Queries In English (SEL)

Official: Google Panda Refresh On November 5th (Version 21) (SER)

Sounds innocent doesn’t it?
However check the SearchMetrics graphs.  1.1% of English queries might not sound high but there is nothing about exactly WHAT type of queries we are talking about.

The conclusion I have come to is below:

  • The SearchMetrics data is correct;
  • No-one expected a Panda update;
  • Next week’s updates will give an answer to the major question – was this just a glitch or are these drops more permanent and related to the Panda update?

Take a look at the pictures below:

What about you guys? Have you noticed any fluctuation in search visibility?

Written by +Lukasz Zelezny

I am +Lukasz Zelezny, a London living SEO Evangelist and conference speaker. I was working for FindAProperty, PrimeLocation, ThomsonReuters, HomeAway and others. Apart from SEO I am a drum and bass producer and traveller who loves north part of the planet Earth. Follow me at @LukaszZelezny and contact via LinkedIn http://www.linkedin.com/in/seomanagerlondon. Find more at Zelezny.uk.
Show all articles from .

Comments (3)

Comments (5)

  1. 2012/11/12

    Haven’t personally seen too many major fluctuations from where I’m at, but there is no telling with these updates. Who knows when we’ll get a freshness update?

    Oh, well. Better stay awake so that Google doesn’t stick our hands in warm water. Thanks for the data.

  2. 2012/11/16

    I’m with Travis on this one. Although we haven’t seen any negative flux in our clients’ metrics, I know better than to shrug it off. I’m keeping an eye on the ever-attacking panda bears!

  3. 2012/11/29

    I have some clients that doest seem to have been effected by this from what I can tell from search metrics. It’s constantly annoying though. Love the picture by the way 🙂

Trackbacks (2)

Comments (5)

  1. 2012/11/09

    […] is the main factor. The first comments from the US are mainly positive, but there are always negative stories. Based on more than 1500 keywords I am tracking for the Dutch market, I see some interesting […]

  2. 2012/11/09

    […] staat.  De resultaten vanuit de US/UK zijn opvallend positief met natuurlijk altijd een aantal verliezers. Op basis van de meer dan 1500 zoekwoorden (voornamelijk travel & e-commerce) die ik dagelijks […]

Write a comment